"Beard’s
primary subject is female silence; she hopes to take a “long view on the
culturally awkward relationship between the voice of women and the public
sphere of speech-making, debate and comment”, the better to get beyond “the
simple diagnosis of misogyny that we tend a bit lazily to fall back on”.
Calling out misogyny isn’t, she understands, the same thing as explaining it,
and it’s only by doing the latter that we’re likely ever to find an effective
means of combating it. The question is: where should we look for answers? Beard
acknowledges that misogyny has multiple sources; its roots are deep and wide.
But in this book, she looks mostly (she is a classicist, after all) at Greek
and Roman antiquity, a realm that even now, she believes, casts a shadow over
our traditions of public speaking, whether we are considering the timbre of a
person’s voice, or their authority to pronounce on any given subject.
Personally,
I might have found this argument a bit strained a month ago; 3,000 years lie
between us and Homer’s Odyssey, which is where she begins, with
Telemachus effectively telling his mother Penelope to “shut up”. But reading it
in the wake of the Harvey Weinstein scandal, it seems utterly,
dreadfully convincing. Mute women; brutal men; shame as a mechanism for
control; androgyny and avoidance as a strategy for survival. On every page,
bells ring too loudly for comfort."